Skip to content

    Bata India

    BATAINDIANeutral
    Consumer Durables·11 Nov 2024
    Management Summary

    Bata India reported muted revenue growth in Q2 FY25, but saw sequential improvement throughout the quarter. The company highlighted strong performance in premium brands and specific categories like Floatz, while the sub-INR1,000 price point segment continued to face demand challenges. Strategic initiatives like sourcing partner consolidation and zero-based merchandising pilots showed promising results, aimed at improving efficiency and consumer experience.

    Highlights

    8
    • Revenue grew by a muted 2.2% YoY.

    • EBITDA margin stood at 22.9% of turnover.

    • PBT was 8.4% as a percentage of turnover.

    • Sourcing partner base reduced by 39%, targeting 45% by year-end and another 20% next year.

    • Zero-based merchandising pilot in 8 stores showed a 60% reduction in lines and a 20% increase in sales per square foot.

    • Franchise store count reached 600, and Hush Puppies stores expanded to 136.

    • Floatz brand continues strong growth, with weekly sales nearing 25,000-27,000 pairs.

    • Contribution of price points below INR1,000 declined from ~40% to ~30% over the last four quarters.

    What Changed2

    vs Q3 FY25

    Tone shiftGood → NeutralGuidance items7 → 10 (+3)

    Key financials

    Single quarter

    04 metrics
    1. 01Revenue Growth2.2%+2.2%YoY
    2. 02EBITDA Margin22.9%
    3. 03PBT Margin8.4%
    4. 04Gross Margin Dip140 bps

    Guidance & targets

    10
    CategoryTargetPriority
    Supply Chain
    Sourcing Partner Reduction
    45%
    High
    Supply Chain
    Sourcing Partner Reduction
    20%
    High
    Supply Chain
    Target Sourcing Partners
    50 to 60
    Medium
    Retail Operations
    Zero-Based Merchandising Rollout
    20% of network (250 top stores)
    High
    Brand Strategy
    Hush Puppies Contract Renewal
    10 years
    High
    Brand Strategy
    Power EBO Opening Plans
    first EBO
    Medium
    Brand Performance
    Floatz Growth
    25% plus
    High
    Product Category
    Apparel Growth Threshold
    threshold
    Medium
    Capex
    PUDIP Plant Installation
    installed
    High
    Capex
    IT Projects Capex
    largely done
    High

    Risks & concerns

    7
    RiskSeverity

    Muted overall growth and demand environment

    Overall growth was 2.2%, with sequential improvement but still muted, and management noted it's 'very difficult to predict' a turnaround.Management acknowledged

    medium

    Underperformance of lower price point portfolio

    The contribution of price points below INR1,000 declined from ~40% to ~30%, struggling from demand perspective due to GST changes and raw material inflation.Management acknowledged

    medium

    Gross margin contraction

    Gross margin was lower by about 140 basis points, partly due to higher franchise/e-commerce mix and inventory clearance efforts, though management is comfortable with medium-term outlook.Management acknowledged

    medium

    Potential disruption from new sizing system

    Management believes Bata is well-prepared due to involvement in setting standards, but acknowledges technical implications for the industry, especially for importers.Analyst downplayed

    low

    Areas of Evasion(3)

    • Hush Puppies license fee
    • Absolute gross margin numbers
    • Exact market share data for specific price points

    Q&A highlights

    3

    “The second thing that's happened is obviously this kind of inflation has been seen by consumers all across, and which is where now the predisposition is towards trying to ensure that we are able to get more and more affordability going back to consumers, while they obviously need to also become a far more comfortable in terms of opening up their wallets, especially the middle and mass segment.”

    Highlights a significant shift in a key price segment for Bata, impacting volumes and potentially market share, driven by GST and raw material inflation.

    asked by Sameer Gupta

    3 min read7 chapters

    Detailed Narrative

    01

    Q2 FY25 Performance Overview

    Bata India reported a muted revenue growth of 2.2% for Q2 FY25, showing sequential improvement from July to September. The company achieved an EBITDA margin of 22.9% and a PBT margin of 8.4% as a percentage of turnover. Gross margin experienced a dip of approximately 140 basis points, which management attributed to a changing channel mix and efforts to clear inventory, expressing comfort with the medium-term gross margin outlook.

    02

    Strategic Initiatives & Operational Efficiency

    The company is actively implementing strategic initiatives to enhance efficiency. Sourcing partner consolidation has reduced the base by 39%, with a target to achieve 45% reduction by year-end and an additional 20% next year, aiming for 50-60 partners. A pilot of zero-based merchandising in eight stores demonstrated significant improvements, including a 60% reduction in store lines and a 20% increase in sales per square foot, with plans to roll out to 20% of the network (250 top stores) in the coming quarters.

    03

    Brand & Portfolio Performance

    Specific brands showed strong performance, with Floatz continuing its robust growth trajectory, achieving weekly sales of 25,000-27,000 pairs and expected to exit the next quarter with over 25% growth. Power outpaced overall business growth with slightly higher single-digit growth, contributing mid-double digits to turnover. The Hush Puppies contract was renewed for 10 years, and its store count expanded to 136, while Bata Comfit also recorded strong double-digit growth.

    04

    Distribution & Channel Expansion

    Bata India expanded its distribution footprint, reaching a landmark of 600 franchise stores, which are crucial for accessing unique towns and market share. The company's owned and operated (COCO) stores now total 1,355. Digital commerce remains the fastest-growing channel, with Omuni contributing 5% to the total turnover. Additionally, the company launched the Nine West brand exclusively on a marketplace and expanded Power EBOs to four locations.

    05

    Affordability & Price Point Strategy

    The contribution of price points below INR1,000 has seen a notable decline from approximately 40% to 30% over the last four quarters, primarily due to GST changes and raw material inflation. Management is focusing on enhancing affordability and value propositions through collections like Easyslide and Energy series to attract consumers, while simultaneously observing continued strong performance in higher price point segments (above INR1,000).

    06

    Manufacturing & Supply Chain Investments

    Bata's sourcing strategy involves 25% in-house manufacturing and 75% from partners. The company is investing in advanced, automated manufacturing technologies, including an injected molded Eva plant operating at full capacity. A new polyurethane direct ingestion (PUDIP) plant, representing a higher investment, is expected to be installed by the March quarter, aiming to improve quality, service levels, and cost efficiency.

    07

    Industry & Demand Outlook

    The overall consumption environment is characterized by mixed trends, with premium segments showing better performance and lower-tier towns exhibiting a slightly stronger response compared to larger towns. Management is optimistic about continued recovery driven by the upcoming wedding season and festive occasions. However, they acknowledge the difficulty in predicting a broader market turnaround, emphasizing a focus on value proposition and consumer engagement.

    This is an AI-generated summary of a publicly available earnings call transcript. It is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation, or an endorsement. inve.money is not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. Please consult a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.