Open Research & Empirical Benchmarks
Last updated: November 16, 2026
Alongside the product, Inve publishes peer-citable empirical studies and aggregate benchmark tables under open licences so journalists, analysts, researchers and newsletter authors can audit and cite base rates on corporate disclosure without a paywall.
Flagship Working Paper (CC BY 4.0)
Working Paper · Published 5 September 2026 · CC BY 4.0
Guidance That Never Closes: Measuring Abandoned Management Commitments in Earnings Calls
Across 24,328 management commitments extracted from 8,220 earnings call transcripts covering 1,648 listed Indian companies (1,654 companies with parsed transcripts), 16,842 commitments have had at least one subsequent call on which they could resolve. Of those resolvable commitments, 9,734 (57.8% pooled; 56.7% mean of per-company rates) were delivered or remained on track, while 2,271 (13.5% of resolvable; 9.3% of all tracked) were never mentioned again on any subsequent analysed earnings call — neither achieved, missed, nor formally withdrawn. At least one such silent commitment appears in 1,000 of 1,648 companies (60.7%).
Abandonment Rate by Guidance Category
Lower-bound category breakdown across the 16,842 resolvable commitments (re-derived from production on 5 September 2026, India-only universe):
| Commitment category | Abandoned / resolvable | Abandonment rate | Total tracked | Companies |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Working capital / debtor / inventory days | 71 / 279 | 25.4% | 372 | 277 |
| Capital expenditure (Capex) | 147 / 750 | 19.6% | 1,041 | 644 |
| Dividend / payout / buyback | 15 / 102 | 14.7% | 129 | 119 |
| Overall resolvable baseline (all categories) | 2,271 / 16,842 | 13.5% | 24,328 | 1,648 |
| Debt / deleveraging | 68 / 511 | 13.3% | 677 | 457 |
| Revenue-scoped subset (consolidated & segment) | 261 / 2,920 | 8.9% | 4,468 | 1,293 |
Full state distribution across all 24,328 tracked commitments: 7,486 new (awaiting a later call) · 5,203 on track · 3,558 achieved · 2,380 missed · 2,271 ghosted (silent) · 880 at risk · 800 delayed · 638 revised down · 597 revised up · 376 achieved (diluted) · 137 diluted · 2 achieved (delayed).
Mandatory Methodological Caveats
Anyone quoting these base rates in journalism, newsletters or academic work should keep four scope limits attached to the numbers:
- Earnings-call scope only: “Never mentioned again” means absent from subsequent earnings calls in our parsed corpus. Targets addressed solely in exchange press releases, annual reports or investor days are outside the corpus.
- Upper-leaning estimate: Corpus depth averages 4.18 analysed quarters per company, and a due commitment qualifies after one silent subsequent call; 13.5% is therefore an upper-leaning estimate rather than a long-horizon point estimate.
- LLM-assisted coding without human-coded holdout: Commitments and statuses were extracted via structured LLM pipelines (Gemini 2.5 Pro on 1,469 company records; Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview on 179 records) without a human-coded inter-rater validation sample. Category counts are keyword-matched lower bounds on free-text metric labels. For that reason, we publish aggregate base rates openly and do not publish unverified bulk row-level adverse labels on named issuers.
- No inference of intent: Commitments lapse for ordinary commercial reasons (segment reorganisation, macro shifts, leadership transitions) as well as quiet abandonment.
How to Cite (Press, Substack & Academic)
Text, charts and aggregate tables on this page may be cited freely under CC BY 4.0 with attribution to the author and DOI:
Aravind R (2026). "Guidance That Never Closes: Measuring Abandoned Management Commitments in Earnings Calls." Inve Working Paper, 5 September 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22337300
Explore the live product surfaces behind this corpus on the India Guidance Tracker, analysed Indian concalls, our methodology, and our editorial policy. For media or research-data enquiries, write to info@inve.money.